|
|
BEST PRACTICES FOR CODE COMPLIANCE AT TOP AEC FIRMS |
|
"Your permit application has been rejected!" This verdict of the building official, heard too often by architects, engineers and contractors, marks the beginning of a struggle.
Code books are brought out once again as the design team scrambles to resolve code violations. Some are easily handled by switching the door swings. But others? Not so easy. And most likely not so cheap. Some of these changes can increase the budget of the project, create back charges and even cause lawsuits.
Additionally, not all code violations are caught during the permit review or construction administration processes. After the certificate of occupancy, performance issues are even harder and more expensive to resolve. And if missed violations are related to life safety, the well being of people -the design team’s ultimate responsibility- is put at risk.
So the question is, how can we ensure compliance with codes that have such an important impact on life safety and the building’s performance?
We asked three top AEC firms - Perkins+Will, HDR and McCarthy - about their best practices for code compliance. Here is what they had to say.
|
Photo: Courtesy of Perkins+Will
Innovative solutions require a good understanding of code requirements. The Boeing Headquarters in Chicago earned Perkins+Will the Structural Engineers Association of Illinois' "Most Innovative" Design Award for its structural design system that supports the suspended southwest corner of the 36-story, 1.1 million square foot structure. |
PERKINS+WILL
Services: Architecture, Interiors and Urban Design
Employees: 1,600
Offices: 20
ENR Top Design Firms Rank: #40
- William J. Schmalz, AIA, LEED AP - Principal
“ |
Perkins+Will approaches code compliance in several important ways: (1) making the building codes accessible to the entire staff; (2) training the staff so they have a thorough understanding of the principles and requirements of the codes; (3) ensuring, through firm-wide delivery standards, that the documents incorporate the requirements of the codes; and (4) using developments in technology to find new ways to ensure the public safety.
|
First, Perkins+Will makes the building codes and standards available to all of the staff. With over 20 offices and 1,600 employees, and a practice that designs projects throughout the world, it is no longer possible for Perkins+Will to maintain physical libraries for each office with all of the necessary code and standards books.
It is more the rule than the exception for, as examples, the Chicago office to design an educational facility in Saudi Arabia, or for the Los Angeles office to design a hospital in Baltimore. This requires that a wide range of code books be available to each office.
To a large extent, the solution to this problem has been the development of web-based code services, such as MADCAD, which provide access to many of the most frequently needed codes and standards, including the International Building Code, NFPA, ASTM, as well as local codes for New York, Florida, California and other states. By tailoring its MADCAD subscription to the needs of the firm, Perkins+Will gives every staff member access to the majority of codes needed for most projects.
The second way Perkins+Will ensures code compliance is by making sure that the professionals responsible for project delivery understand the principles and requirements of the applicable codes. Through a combination of in-house training and mentoring and outside seminars, Perkins+Will raises the level of code understanding among the staff.
Perkins+Will has a firm-wide Learning+Development program that allows the most experienced people to share their knowledge with the entire firm. Occurring twice each week, the L+D classes cover a broad range of topics, including codes and standards.
Perkins+Will has also recently started a training program focused specifically for people who are on the verge of becoming project architects. A large portion of this program is called Designing to the Code, covering the basics of occupancy requirements, exiting and fire-resistant construction.
For all the value of the large-scale training classes, nothing beats having junior professionals working directly with experienced architects. Each office has a Technical Director responsible for overall project delivery within the office, and our larger offices can have as many as 15 Senior Project Architects, each with 20+ years of experience. The Senior Project Architect serves as a resource to the project team for code-related or technical issues, as well as performing quality control reviews at each project milestone.
This leads to the third step in ensuring code compliance: the Perkins+Will Project Delivery Manual. This document, located virtually on Perkins+Will’s intranet system, establishes the design and documentation requirements for all projects. Critical early deliverables are the Building Code Analysis and the Code Compliance/Life Safety Drawings. The Building Code Analysis identifies, in narrative form, all the code requirements applicable to the project, while the Code Compliance/Life Safety Drawings demonstrate graphically how the building design complies with them. These documents are reviewed and approved by the Senior Project Architect in Schematic Design before the team can proceed to the later phases of design.
With the International Building Code as the basis of most local codes in the U.S and internationally, Perkins+Will makes use of all the resources provided by the International Code Council. Each office is encouraged to have at least one ICC member, so that code interpretations can be requested. Perkins+Will’s Quality Assurance Program incorporates the IBC project checklist, a useful tool for developing code analyses. Additionally, staff is encouraged to participate in outside seminars to gain a better understanding of the IBC.
Finally, technology is giving Perkins+Will new tools in meeting code requirements. As more and more projects are being designed using Building Information Modeling (BIM), Perkins+Will is exploring graphic 4-D demonstrations of exiting from high-occupancy spaces and buildings; this will be valuable in showing the level of safety designed into Perkins+Will buildings.
Through a combination of in-house experience, a comprehensive training program, firm-wide project delivery standards, and new developments in technology, Perkins+Will is meeting its responsibility to provide safe environments for the public.”
|
Photo: Courtesy of HDR
Health care design is one of the most complex areas of practice in the building industry which requires compliance with a long list of codes and standards. Designing the American Family Children's Hospital in a site with significant constraints did not stop HDR from receiving multiple awards for this pediatric medical facility, including “Healthcare Project of the Year” Award by Midwest Construction Magazine. |
HDR
Services: Architecture, Engineering and Construction
Employees: 7,900
Offices: 179
ENR Top Design Firms Rank: #13
- Richard M. Horeis, AIA, NFPA, ICC - Director, Technical Review Services, Professional Associate
“ |
At HDR, architects and engineers are required to understand how a specific code will influence their design, just as they are required to know how to apply theory specific to their discipline.
|
All levels of production are expected to utilize codes applicable to their projects. It is understood that as an inexperienced individual may have limited ability to lead a design effort, that same individual will have limited exposure to design codes; whether those codes are building, life safety, electrical, mechanical or structural. But that inexperience does not excuse them from attempting to research the codes.
Quite often the challenge to the code-inexperienced staff is to 'look it up'. HDR has experienced individuals who are focused on codes; that when an answer cannot be found by a staff member, will either assist the production teams or do research themselves to get the answers.
Each project, at the outset, is required to have at the least, primary codes defined. This is probably the easiest question to research. Typically the question can be answered online, or identified by contacting the local authority or authorities having jurisdiction.
Not all code issues can be resolved at the front end of a project; as the design of the facility develops, so does the code analysis. Project review milestones performed by independent (from the project), experienced architects and engineers assure that not only proper design practices are occurring, but also proper code compliance.
As far as being aware of the latest codes and developments, HDR is subscribed to the appropriate code agencies so that employees can receive notifications and updates to the codes. The major code agencies usually also publish a document identifying the updated elements.
Working not only nationally, but also internationally there are many state and municipal codes that have to be maintained and complied with. These changes are monitored and identified to the appropriate offices and staff. However, the staff 'local' to a project is ultimately responsible for maintaining their code database. There is nothing equal to discussing a project with the AHJ early and often.
HDR does keep hard copies of most codes in-house as some still like the weight and feel of the book. Newer on-line accessibility has been provided by organizations such as ICC and NFPA; but HDR also utilizes MADCAD as a 'one-stop-shop' for most of the design codes (all disciplines) we use. If a hard copy of a section is needed, a printer usually is not too far. The online systems are user friendly and are much easier to 'carry' to the job site with a laptop.
Typically, I (and others at HDR) attend seminars put on by ICC, NFPA, ASHE, etc.; especially when new codes are issued. When critical code changes come to light, in-house training is provided, normally through Lunch and Learn programs. We do register these programs with the appropriate associations, such as the AIA so that appropriate credits are awarded to the attendees.”
|
Rendering: Courtesy of McCarthy
In the recent West Georgia Health Systems - South Tower project in LaGrange, Georgia, McCarthy’s field staff created a master verification checklist from referenced codes and standards, specifications, and the subcontractor shop drawings. The checklist was then used to verify that construction met all of the design requirements. |
MCCARTHY BUILDING COMPANIES
Services: Commercial Construction
Employees: 1,700
Offices: 9
ENR Top Contractors Rank: #18
- Chad Meadows - Southeast Division Quality Director
- Chad Dorgan, P.E., Ph.D, LEED AP - Vice President, Corporate Quality
“ |
There are no two projects at McCarthy that are the same. Located from coast to coast, our projects are complex in nature and include high technology facilities such as hospitals, research laboratories and industrial plants. This diversity means that each project has unique contract requirements, building codes and project-specific requirements.
|
Due to the complex nature of our projects and their inherent risk, McCarthy has established a proactive and integrated Quality Program. This Quality without Question program establishes client expectations early in the project, with a focus on understanding the details within the project specifications and drawings. This is where having online access to codes and standards becomes an important part of the quality planning process.
Quality planning starts with a review of the specifications, during which our project staff takes note of the referenced codes and standards to understand what the designer is asking us to build to. It is at this point in planning where access to MADCAD becomes a McCarthy differentiator for our clients. Instead of simply looking up the specific codes and standards, we read these in the context of our Quality Process, thus identifying unique aspects of the codes and standards that need to be verified at key points during the project. These verifications include review of the subcontractor’s shop drawings and product data, delivery of equipment and materials, pre-installation meetings, first installation verifications, ongoing verifications and testing, system start-up and project closeout.
For example, on a recent hospital project in the Southeast, our field staff combined the key information from the referenced codes and standards, the specifications, and the subcontractor shop drawings into a master verification checklist. This checklist was then used at the very start of the installation process to verify that construction met all of the design requirements. The checklist was then utilized for follow-up inspections throughout the duration of the installation.
Online access to both historic and the most up-to-date codes and standards helps our engineers, superintendents and managers provide our clients with Quality without Question.”
|
|
|
|
SEARCHING AT MADCAD.com |
|
Would you like to experience the ease and speed of searching at MADCAD.com?
Simply click on one of the keywords below to start searching across more than 7,000 codes and standards.
SEARCH: delayed egress, fire extinguisher or smoke barrier.
If you have any questions, please contact Erdem Dedebas at ededebas@madcad.com or (202) 265-1940 x207.
Trial expires on 6/27/2009. |
|
|
|
MORE INDUSTRY NEWS |
|
NATION'S LARGEST SOLAR PLANT TO BE BUILT IN NM
Utility officials announced plans Thursday to build a giant solar energy plant in the New Mexico desert in what is believed to be the largest... Read more
MAY HOUSING CONSTRUCTION JUMPS BY 17.2 PERCENT
Construction of new homes jumped in May by the largest amount in three months, an encouraging sign that the nation's deep housing... Read more |
|
WALK IN THE PARK? TOKYO RESIDENTS HEAD SKYWARDS
The cramped, concrete jungle that is Tokyo, one of the world's most densely populated cities, has little space for parks. But things are starting... Read more
ART 'IN ITS OWN GLORY' IN BIGGER CLEVELAND MUSEUM
Monet, Renoir, Cezanne, Rodin and other masters are the stars of the biggest expansion in the history of the Cleveland Museum of Art, and that.... Read more |
|
|
|
NEW SUBSCRIBERS TO MADCAD.com |
|
EAST TEXAS MEDICAL CENTER
East Texas Medical Center Regional Healthcare System provides health care services to more than 300,000 patients every year in East Texas. ETMC subscribed to MADCAD.com for online access to the latest editions of the NFPA standards referenced in the Hospital Accreditation Standards of The Joint Commission.
BALTIMORE COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS
As the 26th largest school system in the U.S., Baltimore County Public Schools serves more than 103,000 students in 172 schools, programs and centers. BCPS subscribed to MADCAD.com for the latest ICC and ASHRAE energy codes for energy efficiency.
|
![Baltimore County Public Schools Logo](http://www.madcad.com/newsletters/june09/images/BCPS.jpg)
![East Texas Medical Center Logo](http://www.madcad.com/newsletters/june09/images/ETMC.jpg) |
|
|
|
KEVIN SURACE INVENTS ECO-FRIENDLY DRYWALL
TED stands for Technology, Entertainment, Design.
In its annual conference, TED brings together the world's most fascinating thinkers and doers, who are challenged to give the talk of their lives.
In this TED Talk, Kevin Surace suggests we rethink basic construction materials -- such as the familiar wallboard -- to reduce the huge carbon footprint generated by the manufacturing and construction of our buildings. He introduces EcoRock, a clean, recyclable and energy-efficient drywall created by his team at Serious Materials.
Kevin Surace is looking at the climate crisis from an engineer's perspective -- and creating products that prove there's no piece of our daily lives we can't redesign to be cleaner and greener.
|
|
|
COMMENTS FROM OUR READERS |
|
RE: BUILDING CODE TREND FAVORS FIRE SPRINKLER
According to the Home Safety Council, NFPA, and other leading authorities on fires and fire statistics only a small percentage (29% to be exact) of citizens in the United States are literate enough to read a book or an instruction manual, comprehend and retain its contents. I’m not really sure average citizens should be making decisions about his or his next-door neighbor’s life safety.
As far as construction type, it is not the structure that is normally the ignition source; it is the content of the structure. In our ever changing world of disposable furnishings and property, most products purchased today for the home are made of highly flammable synthetic materials which are also extremely toxic.
Additionally, in an effort to become “green” with the environment and economy concerns, thermally protected openings such as storm doors, storm windows, double pane glass, etc. all contribute to rapidly rising interior temperatures during a fire which accelerate due to the inability to expel heat. Lives are lost at a much quicker rate in homes today than they were ten years ago or longer when they were built, and technology presses forward.
Yes, fire sprinklers do cost money at the time of construction, but there has never been a loss of life in a properly protected building or home due to fire.
Gary D. Turner, President
Urban Fire Protection
Click here to view the article "Building Code Trend Favors Fire Sprinkler".
|
|
|
Copyright 2009 Compu.tecture, Inc.
All rights reserved. |